Monday, 16 November 2026

Tim Tyler: The common interest of many memes

Transcript:

Hi. I'm Tim Tyler and this is a video about the common interest of many memes.

This is one of those concepts that is quite an important thinking tool - and yet for some reason it didn't make it into my 2011 book on memetics.

Genes are often stronger if they work together. Multi-cellular plants have come to dominate the biosphere, liiterally putting many single-celled organisms into the shade.

They have a trick that helps them to do this - known as a "fair meiosis". The ritual dance of the chromosomes during recombination means that genes can typically only get into the next generation if they cooperate with their team-mates to produce host offspring.

Memes are also stronger if they work together. However, while the genes of their hosts form a united front the world's memes are typicaly much more fragmented and disjoint - pulling their hosts in many different directions. Their reproductive interests are not always well-aligned.

Memes have not really mastered meiosis. They need to find other ways to cooperate with each other. One approach for them is to become part of a religion. Religions are huge memetic constructs that tend to get passed on together and are resistant to fragmentation.

This video is about another approach to meme-to-meme cooperation that some memes have pursued. The basic idea is that some memes share interests due to their shared circumstances. Some examples should help to illustrate the point. One example is that it is in the common interest of many memes to avoid killing their host. There might be a few memes that follow the strategy similar to that of the ebola virus - and burn through all the host resources as quickly as possible. However, it is in the common interest of most other memes to ensure the survival of their host. You can't spread memes around very well - if you are dead.

Next, a list of similar examples:

  • Teaching and preaching skills are in the common interest of many memes - since teachers and preachers are uniquely positioned to transfer many types of meme.
  • Being sociable and friendly is in the common interest of many memes - since social interactions are how many memes reproduce. Influencers do something similar.
  • Another example is that it is in the common interest of many memes to sterilize their hosts. The reason is that the memes can often find a way to divert reproductive resources away from host reproduction and towards meme reproduction. This effect has resulted in the sterility epidemic.
  • Another example involves the host's memetic immune system. Many pathogens attempt to sabotage the immune system of their hosts - to get the upper hand in the conflict between them. For many memes, scepticism and rationality are their enemies and sabotaging and undermining them allows many conspiracy theories free reign.
There are other examples - I don't pretend this is anywhere near a complete list.

The idea here is somewhat related to the idea of "universal instrumental values". Those are values that are useful for pursuing a wide range of goals. Our first example here - "not dying" - often appears on lists of universal instrumental values. Another common universal instrumental value is "resource acquisition". I didn't mention it here until now - but this could also be listed as a common interest of many memes. The concepts are not exactly the same - but they do seem to be related. I have another video titled "Universal instrumental values" - so you can check that out if you would like more details about that.

On that note, it is about time to wrap up this video. If I had to give a one line summary I would say that "the common interest of many memes" is a useful concept for understanding how unrelated memes can sometimes team up with one another - via shared interests arising from shared circumstances.

Enjoy!

Wednesday, 9 July 2025

The infertility epidemic

Human fertility has fallen rapidly in most developed countries over the last few decades. The human population is still growing - but it is now widely forecast that we will read "peak human" in the next few decades.

The topic has attracted attention from various worriers, who are concerned that the fertility fall will eventuall lead to negative consequences - perhaps similar to what is seen to be happening in Japan.

The fall in fertility as countries develop is widely known as "the demographic transition". I prefer another term: "the infertility epidemic". This emphasizes the similarity with past epidemics - such as the smoking epidemic, the AIDS epidemic, the obesity epidemic and the opiod epidemic. The term "infidelity" has some defects - since it typically refers to lack of fertility if people are trying to make babies - whereas the problem here also involves people not even trying to make babies. We could perhaps call it "the childlessness epidemic" if that is seen as a big issue.

What's the cause of the infertility epidemic? This has been treated by various authors. Boyd and Richerson famously explained how cultural evolution caused the demographic transition in "Not By Genes Alone".

As with the other epidemics I mentioned, I favor the symbiote hypothesis: some small, rapidly-reproducing agent is out-evolving the human hosts. Sometimes these are helped along by humans - the smoking and opiod epidemics were spread by advertising and marketing memes from big phood and big pharma - but there were also humans involved in helping these messages on their way.

The symbiote hypothesis typically leaves open the identy of the symbionts - and there may be multiple different kinds involved. For example, the obesity epidemic was spread by memes from fast food companies - but candida albicans was also likely involved.

What symbiotes are involved in the infertility epidemic? I would draw attention to memes. Sterilizing their human hosts is a common interest of many memes - and memes reside in the brain which puts them in a good position to divert host resources from host reproduction into meme reproduction. However, I suspect viruses are also involved.

Many persistent viral infections are also in a position to divert host resources from host reproduction into virus reproduction. Some persistent viral infections are known to negatively impact fertility. HPV is a famous example of human parasite-induced sterility. It blocks the fallopian tubes of women with cancer cells - preventing future births.

While the identity of the symbiotes is of interest, it doesn't really matter for the symbiote hypothesis of infertility - any and all symbiotes will do. What competing theories are there? Predation is a possible cause of failing to thrive. While there are a few cannibals out there, this theory doesn't fit the facts very well. If competition with other large creatures is heavily involved, that would favor competition over parasitism. Certainly some competition is involved. Humans directly manipulate other humans into not having children - and humans compete for resources with large institutions and machines - such as motor cars. However, while competition with larger creatures is part of the story, it looks like a fairly small part - at least at the moment.

References

Friday, 28 February 2025

The problem with Robin Hanson's cultural drift

Robin Hanson has developed an interest in cultural evolution. I've previously blogged about that here. However, I am not sure about some of Robin's claims. He believes that human values are subject to what he calls "cultural drift" - and that we are making too many undirected value changes in a row and so risking going off the rails (adaptively speaking) - resulting in issues like the demographic transition - or the fertility crisis - as we perhaps ought to start calling it.

I wrote up my objections here - and reproduce them in this post:

Why do human values have this problem, while science, math, technology and language do not? That seems fairly simple: science, math, technology and language are places where the interestes of memes and genes are aligned. Whereas values are an area where they are typically different.

It is the common interest of many memes to turn humans into meme spreaders: preachers, teachers and influencers - and to make sure that no DNA-based offspring distract them from this task.

The problem is not anything to do with making too many undirected value changes in a row and then going off the rails. If that was the problem then math, science and technology would have the same issue. It's because human DNA genes now have a powerful opponent. A systematic competitor for reproductive resources.

This is why I am opposed to the "drift" story. It seems like a misdiagnosis of the problem. It makes it harder to solve our problems if we don't have an accurate picture of their causes.

My other objection is to Robin's terminology. I would prefer the term "cultural drift" to be a close synonym of "memetic drift" - the cultural analog of "genetic drift". Robin uses the term differently - claiming that he is using the common meaning of the term "drift" in the dictionary. I think that Robin's somewhat irregular use of terminology likely to cause confusion.

Here is Robin's definition of culture:

But they look more worrisome re the cultural norms and game-theory-equilibria parameters that are hard to change individually, culturally-set features analogous to the harder-to-evolve DNA-set features that define biological species, as compared to DNA-set features that can vary easily within such species. (Biology DNA evolves faster with more smaller species, as that better promotes these more important species-defining features.) I’ll call these features “culture”.

I think a more reasonable term for that is "macro-culture". There's also "micro-culture" - by analogy with "macroeconomics" and "microeconomics".

Sunday, 29 September 2024

Why does the human Y chromosome share more sequences with gorillas than chimpanzees?

This post does not have much to do with memes, but it does relate to early human evolution.

In particular it discusses reticular great ape evolution. The main evidential basis for the post is the observation that gorilla Y chromosomes are more similar to human Y chromosomes than they are to chimpanzee Y chromosomes. This is a widely recognized fact. It is true despite the family tree weakly predicting the opposite finding:

The Y chromosomes of great apes represent a particular puzzle: their gene content is more similar between human and gorilla than between human and chimpanzee, even though human and chimpanzee share a more recent common ancestor.

An obvious and conventional explanation for that is that the chimp lineage experienced rapid Y chromosome evolution, leaving humans and gorillas with relatively similar Y chromosomes. This could have something to do with sperm competition and the huge chimpanzee testicles. That's the conclusion drawn here:

we found that the genus Pan, which includes chimpanzee and bonobo, experienced accelerated substitution rates. Pan also exhibited elevated gene death rates. These observations are consistent with high levels of sperm competition in Pan.

Mystery solved - right? Maybe. Here, I would like to draw attention to another pair of possibilities:

Maybe a male gorilla mated with a female human ancestor - and now all human males are now descended from him. Or maybe the opposite scenario is involved: maybe a male human ancestor mated with a female gorilla and now all male gorillas are descended from him.

I think that we have to downgrade the probability of these explanations since they involve unlikely reticular evolution and hybridization. However, while hybrids are rare I think that geological time up-regulates their potential evolutionary significance. Basically, Eugene McCarthy has convinced me that we should consider hybridization much more seriously.

Can we test these theories? Yes, I think they can be tested using geonomic comparison data. In addition to a similar Y chromosome, we should expect subtle changes in the rest of the genome. Back-crossing would dilute, but perhaps not completely eliminate traces of the hybridization event.

Assuming a male chimpanzee donor, some small areas of the human genome would be less similar to chimpanzees and more similar to gorillas. That's expected anyway, but with hybridization, there would be more donor DNA involved. We could compare in both directions (human -> gorilla and gorilla -> human). If there's a big difference, hybridization becomes more likely. We could possibly even use molecular clocks to determine when shared sequences diverged between the lineages.

Which of the two scenarios I mentioned is more likely? I think that is unclear, but the scenario involving the male gorilla seems as though it would be the more dramatic finding for students of human evolution. Relationships between male gorillas and female humans have been dramatized in King Kong and its sequels. It would be a curious finding if those movies mimicked real evolutionary history.

Tuesday, 27 August 2024

Part Primate, Part Pig

In 1976, Richard Dawkins wrote: "Most of what is unusual about man can be summed up in one word: 'culture'."

Genetic differences between humans and chimpanzees would thus likely be explained by a theory of gene-meme coevolution. Or so I have assumed for a decade or so.

Now a rogue scientist has come up with a very different explanation for the differences between humans and chimpanzees. He substitutes "culture" with "pigs".

"Most of what is unusual about man can be summed up in one word: 'pig'. The hypothesis is that a pig and a great ape mated and produced viable offspring. Some of their genes persisted in the population and eventually came to dominate it. Their descendants are modern humans.

This is not a very new idea. Eugene McCarthy as been promoting it for over a decade. For a while. phenotypic similarities were the main evidence. However, now Eugene has performed a genetic analysis that he claims provides solid evidence for the theory. The paper is: "Human Autosomal Nucleotide Positions Differing from Bonobo Instead Match Pig".

It is an amazing, surprising result. If replicated it will likely turn much of our understanding of human evolution on its head. Eugene's data shows that the Y chromosome has a lot of pig influence, while the X chromosome doesn't have any. This implies that the pig males mated with monkey females - and not the other way around. The Y chromosome doesn't cross over, so it means humans basically have a pig's Y chromosome. How come nobody noticed this before? I don't know, but it does look as though the Y chromosome is similar to that of a pig. Various papers have pointed out its oddities.

The pig Y chromosome estimated to be 50Mb here. That is similar to human at 57 Mb. Different from chimpanzee at 25Mb. The conventional explanation is: more sperm competition in chimps generates selection pressure favoring small size. Another site says: ""Puzzlingly, in terms of shared genes and overall architecture, the human Y is more similar to the gorilla Y than to the chimpanzee Y even though human and chimpanzee have a more recent common ancestor."

The evidence from the sex chromosomes is interesting and it could be easy to verify. However the rest of the genome is where the main evidence lies.

Eugene's study needs to be reviewed and replicated - but it is looking as though this could be an important find for those interested in human evolution.

Update: Eugene checked - and the human Y chromosome is more similar to chimpanzee than it is to pig - according to his metrics. It is consistent with the hypothesis of the hybrid inbvolving a male pig - since the pig Y chromosome could still subsequently go extinct in the population.

For more on the gorilla-related evidence see here.

Saturday, 24 August 2024

Memetic strategies

Here are a few lists of meme-related strategies. The first list was inspired bt an Alex Mesoudi paper that laid out a fairly conventional view aligned with the work of Boyd and Richerson. Sorry, no link today.

What strategies do people (adopters) use to acquire good memes from others (sources)?

  • Are the memes popular?
  • Are the memes repeated?
  • Do the memes attract attention?
  • Do the sources have high-prestige?
  • Are the sources related to the adopters genetically - do they share genes with them?
  • Are the sources related to the adopters in other ways - do they share memes or environment with them?
  • Are the memes likely to benefit the genes of the adopters?
  • Are the memes likely to benefit the existing memes of the adopters?

As well as sources resembling them, the adopters can sometimes be interested in whether the sources resemble the adopters in *relevant* ways.

Some of these strategies can be faked or corrupted. For example, high-prestige people could be being paid to appear to associate with the meme, in order to manipulate others into adopting it. This is a common advertising trick. What strategies do memes use to get acquired by others?

  • Be memorable
  • Be copyable
  • Acquire and gain control over resources
  • Promise to benefit the host - and deliver on the promise.

To persist in their new host, candidate memes typically have to pass additional hurdles once acquired:

  • Are the memes compatible with existing attitudes and beliefs?
  • Are the memes sufficiently memorable?
  • Prevent rival memes from being adopted
  • Destroy rival memes already present in the host
  • Do the memes cause conflict or trouble?
  • Are the memes useful or helpful?
  • If memes do not appear to be helpful, might they be so in the future?

  • Wednesday, 14 August 2024

    Robin Hanson - Beware cultural drift

    Robin Hanson has become interested in cultural evolution in 2024. He read Not By Genes Alone, The Secret of our Success, Cognitive Gadgets: The Cultural Evolution of Thinking - and a number of other books on the topic. He has also made some blog posts and videos in the area. Here's a recent video on the topic:

    My picture seems significantly different from Robin's. I see meme reproduction at the expense of gene reproduction - likely followed by a machine takeover. I do not forsee innovation grinding to a halt - instead intelligent machines will promote innovation. Robots will become the main consumers. The economy is unlikely to go into decline. The Amish are irrelevant - their rise is too slow to make a difference. We didn't break civilization and civilization is unlikely to collapse. I suspect that the basic problem is that Robin's timelines for the development of machine intelligence are too long.

    Rob Boyd & Pete Richerson - Cultural Evolution, Human Brain Increases, AGI, & Fertility Declines

    A new Boyd & Richerson interview:

    Thursday, 11 April 2024

    Are AIs really our descendants?

    While I'm criticising the positions of Robin Hanson, I reviewed his 2023 article titled: "AIs Will Be Our Mind Children" - which contains the following:

    But — and here is my main point, so please listen carefully — future human-level AIs are not co-existing competing aliens; they are instead literally our descendants. So if your evolved instincts tell you to fight your descendants due to their strangeness, that is a huge evolutionary mistake. Natural selection just does not approve of your favoring your generation over future generations. Natural selection in general favors instincts that tell you to favor your descendants, even those who differ greatly from you.
    I think this paragraph shows a basic failure to distingush between memes and genes. Robin says as much - by defining "genes" as follows:

    Your “genes” are whatever parts of you code for your and your descendants’ behaviours.

    That definition classifies memes as genes. AIs are our "Mind Children". They are likely inherit from our memes, but not from our DNA genes - at least not unless we expend considerable effort to preserve information in our genes.

    You can't just throw around terms like "descendants" and "generations" in the way that Robin does. Descendants on which lineage? Generations of which lineage? Are we talking about memes or genes here? It really does matter. What Robin is doing is "muddling together" all forms of inheritance.

    To call such machines our "descendants" ignores the fact that modern organisms - like humans - are menageries. They contain many indpendent inheritance pathways. Each has its own notion of what consitututes a "generation". Machines will inherit from our memes, but our genes are unlikely to be impressed by that. Rather they will complain about their germ line being wiped out. We do indeed see protests of exactly that kind. This is not a "huge evolutionary mistake" as Robin claims - instead it is one lineage complaining about competition with another lineage.

    Natural selection does not favor instincts that tell you to favor your descendants indiscriminantly. According to Robin's classification scheme, excreted gut bacteria are classified as "descendants". It seems as though my DNA genes are likely to get prioity treatment if there is much of a conflict of interest.

    Overall, I was not very impressed with Robin's argument here.

    References

    The demographic transition revisited

    I have an existing article about "Memes and the demographic transition". It has a number of pointers and references, but I reviewed it recently and one thing it doesn't really have is a brief summary of the theory. So, here goes:

    Memes are the cause of the modern fertility fall now seen in most western nations. The phenomenon is widely known as "the demographic transition". How does that work? Like this:

    • Organisms are typically resource-limited;
    • Memes compete for reproductive resources with DNA genes;
    • Memes are getting the upper hand in this battle due to a number of factors including progress;
    • Meme interests are now less aligned with host interests due to meme horizontal transmission.
    That's it. Between them these four points explain the vast majority of the dynamics of the demographic transition.

    To unpack the points:

    • Resource limitation - means that resources available for one application are not available for other appications. In other words using resources is subject to an opportunity cost. Resource limitation is ubiquitous.
    • Memes and genes compete for resources - resources spent producing babies and DNA genes are resources not spent on learning and propagaing memes - and visa versa.
    • Memes are winning - or at least their power and influence are rising.
    • More memes are parasitic - This is due to horizontal transmission of memes with respect to the host generations. Once, humans lived in small groups and got many of their memes from family members. This is no longer the case and most memes are obtained via "horizontal" transmission. This path is more likely to be occupied by parasites. Some will behave like the Ebola virus: liquidate their host as fast as possible. Others will merely sterilize their hosts and redirect their resources into meme propagation.

    For more details and some references, see the "Memes and the demographic transition article.

    This article is partly in response to Robin Hanson's article titled: Beware Cultural Drift.

    Robin claims: "The clearest proof of biologically maladaptive culture drift is fertility". That does not seem right to me. "Drift" has a specific meaning in biology - it refers to the absence of selection. Here the memes are not "drifting" away from some adaptive peak. They are actively and deliberately sabotaging the fertility of their human hosts and using the resulting resources for their own ends. Drift is a sideshow.